[Why won't Donovan apologize to the Villa family? Will we need a court order?]
Readers, below here is the 3-minute exposé essay I delivered at Allentown City Council on Wednesday evening July 21 (I really enjoy public speaking). I actually wrote it to time out at 2 and a half minutes so that I could encourage City Council and all those assembled to use my final 30 seconds of "Courtesy of the Floor" time to reflect silently on City Council VP (for now) "W" Mike Donovan" who was absent and hiding under a rock somewhere. I noticed that the 5 City Council members at the dais (Councilman Schweyer was a no-show too) all used their 30 seconds of "Donovan Reflection Time" to give me icy dagger stares. Gee. I must have this all backwards. See I think Donovan is the bad guy in this story, but obviously City Council thinks I'm the problem. Oh well. Repetition is the mother of learning.
The meeting had started out jovially enough, with promise-ignoring Council President Mike D'Amore barreling into Council Chambers and immediately heading for the "press box" at the back of the room to back-slap and yuk it up w/ Morning Call "newspaper" "reporter" Jarrett Renshaw and self-proclaimed "professional blogger" Chris Casey. Subtle.
At least my pal Allentown Chief of Police Roger MacLean was there and we exchanged warm pleasantries (including a hug where I think he frisked me), although I forgot to assure Roger that come 2011 he won't have to deal w/ (hiccup) Jim Martin anymore. When Chief MacLean got up to speak at the microphone on an issue, I got up and took D'Amore's empty seat in the "press box" w/ Chris Casey and sat right next to Jarrett Renshaw and a hovering cop for half an hour.
Anyways, here's what I said at the podium, and FYI, I'll be doing an encore performance of this at the next City Council meeting on August 4, when, hopefully, "W" Mike Donovan and all the TV news crews will be back from "vacation" (wink wink).
"I'm Bill Villa from Allentown here to report that right after my debut visit to City Council on June 16th, Council VP Donovan deleted the hundreds of sadistically cruel and libelous comments he had knowingly encouraged against my family at his blog for the entire month of March 2010.
Those fun comments at Donovan's blog (and I gave you hard copy on June 16th) implied and asserted that I engage in necrophilia with my deceased daughter Sheena ... that I drink my own urine ... that I snort Sheena's ashes ... that my wife Angie is going to hell ... and that my still living 8 year old son Gianni is poison.
Donovan could have deleted those vile comments back in March when they were posted but he didn't. He also could have deleted them after my Ethics Board complaint against him, or after he expressed his "concern" about his blog’s comments on 69 News on June 2nd but he didn't delete them then either.
Only when Donovan found out I emailed City Council links to his cyber terror against my family ... so you could read Donovan's vile for yourselves, did Donovan first change his blog design so the links I sent you wouldn't work ... and then he mass-deleted those hundreds of sadistically cruel comments in a public admission of guilt and wrongdoing.
Clearly it was wrong for City Council Vice President Donovan to knowingly encourage Chris Casey of Trexlertown and [Redacted] to post and sign all those vile comments against my family at Donovan’s blog.
Mr. Hanlon [City Clerk and Timekeeper], I'd now like to use the balance of my time for all of us to quietly consider the outrageousness of Michael Donovan's cyber cruelty against my family."
Tick. Tick. Tick.
55 comments:
You done good, again.
It takes a lot of courage to stand up for what you believe is right--and there's no doubt you are right in this matter.
Thank you. Please see our right sidebar content for other matters we're right about ...
The fact that Donovan won't apologize only proves that he was a willing (duped) accomplice all along.
Well said, we agree.
------------
Email, Outgoing, to Allentown City Council, cc'd to City Clerk Mike Hanlon, Mayor Ed Pawlowski ...
On Jul 22, 2010, at 10:15:34 AM, Bill Villa wrote:
Please feel free to add this to the record, see you next on August 4.
Donovan Runs & Hides From Apology Showdown Meeting at City Council
Bill Villa
610.428.xxxx
Readers, nouveau environmental activist Andrew Kleiner was there last night for the pre-meeting discussion about South Mountain.
Andrew was "friends" w/ my daughter Sheena and her brother Patrick. They went to school together. Andrew used to be very friendly w/ me too whenever I'd stop in for a coffee at Hava Java where Andrew used to work.
It was the first time we were seeing each other in person since Andrew's friend Sheena was killed.
Kleiner totally ignored me.
Blogging professionally at work ...
Domain Name > covad.net
IP Address > 72.244.66.# (Covad Communications)
Time of Visit > Jul 22 2010 10:20:13 am
Visit Length > 28 minutes 23 seconds
Bill you are admired by many, keep fighting the good fight!
Jarrett Renshaw has a nose for news ...
Domain Name > (Unknown)
IP Address > 163.192.12.# (Tribune Company)
ISP > The Morning Call
Time of Visit > Jul 22 2010 1:02:21 pm
Time of Visit > Jul 22 2010 12:51:20 pm
Time of Visit > Jul 22 2010 12:25:37 pm
Time of Visit > Jul 22 2010 11:09:29 am
Time of Visit > Jul 22 2010 10:52:57 am
Time of Visit > Jul 22 2010 9:54:04 am
Time of Visit > Jul 22 2010 9:44:21 am
Merci, 1:02, they don't stand a snow ball's chance in hell against me, the lot of them.
Welcome,
justice is always welcome here ...
Domain Name > usdoj.gov (U.S. Government)
IP Address > 149.101.1.# (US Dept of Justice)
ISP > US Dept of Justice
State > District of Columbia
Time of Visit > Jul 22 2010 11:45:06 am
Email, Outgoing, to Lehigh County Democrats ...
On Jul 22, 2010, at 2:38:02 PM, Bill Villa wrote:
Democrats, please don't support "W" Mike Donovan for any elected office in Lehigh County, as Donovan holding any office is a tragic mistake.
Read my note and blog post to Allentown City Council for the details.
And thanks as always for your consideration.
Best Regards,
Bill Villa
610.428.xxxx
P.S. At this juncture, how many candidates do you have lined up for a successful run against Lehigh County District (hiccup) Attorney Jim Martin in 2011 ...
"Tick. Tick. Tick."
WOW! WHAT GREAT POLITICAL THEATRE!
MUST SEE TV!
Definitely, and it could be a bi-monthly FEATURE STORY, if Donkey Donovan keeps refusing to apologize.
w/ more & more frequency,
LVS is attracting "out of town talent,"
just sayin' ...
Domain Name > (Unknown)
IP Address > 161.188.204.# (Philadelphia Newspapers)
ISP > Philadelphia Newspapers
City > Philadelphia
Time of Visit > Jul 22 2010 2:51:41 pm
Very cool ...
------------
Email, Outgoing, to Allentown City Clerk Mike Hanlon.
On Jul 22, 2010, at 3:18:10 PM, Bill Villa wrote:
Subject Heading: M.I.A. City Councilors
Mike, have any of the City Councilors given notice that he or she won't be attending the August 4 meeting ...
Bill Villa
610.428.xxxx
Email, Incoming, from Allentown City Clerk Mike Hanlon.
On Jul 22, 2010, at 3:46:06 PM, Mike Hanlon wrote:
No
----------
((Me))
Great. I'll book the TV news crews.
Hey Mike, your opinion, should Donovan apologize ... or ... should he "stand his ground" and insist on his right to libel and emotionally cyber-torture a grief-stricken Allentown family?
Do you have a position on this?
Just curious, since your daughter knew my daughter Sheena and all ...
Bill Villa
610.428.xxxx
... must be a stumper Q.
Mike Hanlon typically gets back to me (on average) in 30 minutes or less ... Tick. Tick. Tick.
Email, Outgoing, to Allentown City Councilman Julio Guridy ...
On Jul 22, 2010, at 5:14:07 PM, Bill Villa wrote:
Julio, your opinion please ...
should Donovan apologize to my family and me ...
or ... should he "stand his ground" and insist on his right to libel and emotionally cyber-torture a grief-stricken Allentown family?
Do you have a position on this?
Just curious, since you and I are both longtime friends with the Huertes family ...
Bill Villa
610.428.xxxx
Jarrett Renshaw has a nose for news ...
Domain Name > (Unknown)
IP Address > 163.192.12.# (Tribune Company)
ISP > The Morning Call
Time of Visit > Jul 22 2010 5:03:02 pm
Time of Visit > Jul 22 2010 4:12:25 pm
Time of Visit > Jul 22 2010 3:27:30 pm
Time of Visit > Jul 22 2010 1:54:33 pm
Time of Visit > Jul 22 2010 1:02:21 pm
Time of Visit > Jul 22 2010 12:51:20 pm
Time of Visit > Jul 22 2010 12:25:37 pm
Time of Visit > Jul 22 2010 11:09:29 am
Time of Visit > Jul 22 2010 10:52:57 am
Time of Visit > Jul 22 2010 9:54:04 am
Time of Visit > Jul 22 2010 9:44:21 am
Readers, FYI, I'm not gonna bother polling City Councilors D'Amore, Schlossberg, and Schweyer as all 3 are card-carrying members of Team Donovan/Casey/Renshaw/Satan.
How 'bout Donovan?
See LVS's right sidebar item on Nutty Professor Jeff Pooley entitled, "Take The Pooley Pledge."
Domain Name > muhlenberg.edu
IP Address > 192.104.181.# (Muhlenberg College)
ISP > Muhlenberg College
City > Allentown
Time of Visit > Jul 22 2010 5:35:31 pm
"New Boy Network."
Meet the new boss, same as (or worse than) the old boss.
How about it ...
it's incredible really ...
Email, Incoming, from Allentown City Councilman Julio Guridy.
On Jul 23, 2010, at 9:51:57 AM, Julio Guridy wrote:
Good morning, Bill. Quite frankly, I have been avoiding the issue because I know you for a long time and also because I have to work with Donovan as my colleague in City Council. I think this has gotten personal between you two and I do not want to get involved, nor take any side. My opinion is that at this time this issue doesn’t belong in the legislative body of the City. Lastly, I believe that it is a civil issue that you and Donavan should deal with outside of the City Council Chambers
Julio.
--------
((Me))
Julio, while I appreciate you finally getting back to me, and hope you are doing well, I am deeply disappointed that you "do not want to get involved," "nor take any side" in this serious personal and public matter that involves the current Vice President of the City Council on which you currently serve.
There's no gray area here when it comes to Donovan's wrongdoing-- clearly it was wrong for Donovan to (in his own words) "just let all comments run because they are fun to read," as Donovan gave Chris Casey and [Redacted] carte blanche the entire month of March 2010 to defile my deceased daughter Sheena, my wife Angie, my son Gianni, and myself-- at a blog Donovan uses to speak to constituents as a City Councilor, i.e., as a legislator.
Equally crystal clear here is what the "right thing to do" is: for Donovan to apologize to my family and me.
Choosing to "not get involved," "nor to take any side" ... when you could be choosing to apply pressure on Donovan to apologize, and bring this shameful episode in Allentown legislator history to a definitive close ... is very disappointing.
Prior to receiving this email from you, I had been impressed with both your integrity, and your leadership qualities.
Bill Villa
610.428.xxxx
TO WHOM IT MAY CONCERN
When I posted the above email exchange between Julio Guridy and myself, I inadvertently included a name that shouldn't have been in there. This was purely accidental and was fixed immediately, as can be seen by comparing the time on all of your printouts of the infraction comment w/ the re-post time of Fri Jul 23, 11:10:00 AM 2010. The multiple (corrected) posts were the result of a "Blogger" error message glitch that was telling me (repeatedly) that the comment was "too large to post." But then "Blogger" posted all my attempts, and I subsequently deleted the duplicates. Mea Culpa for any confusion.
What's crystal clear here is that City Council members don't really give a shit about their constituents, even those who volunteer their time to help the city. Silence is acceptance. Ignoring Donovan's very public behavior at his blog sends the message that it's okay for elected Allentown officials to endorse lies and smears that could destroy the good name and reputation of Allentown residents. Vote 'em all out. They only "care" about you when they need your vote. Shameful.
Email, Forward, to Allentown City Council (minus Donovan), plus Allentown City Clerk Mike Hanlon, Allentown Mayor Ed Pawlowski ...
On Jul 23, 2010, at 11:39:21 AM, Bill Villa wrote:
Julio, I hope you don't mind, but I wanted to share our email exchange with City Council, minus Donovan. Ray, and Jeanette, I'd still like to hear back from you ... thanks for your consideration ...
Bill Villa
610.428.xxxx
Let's review...Council Prez DAmore and Mayor Pawlowski have done zero on this....the "Ethics" Board kicked their responsibility can clear down the road....City Council doesn't want to get involved...the Morning Call is hnot telling the whole true story here....and the "Watchdog" local blogosphere is M.I.A. Some place, "Allentown."
Readers, the reason I've stopped including Donovan in my email exchanges w/ City Council is because Donovan keys-in "Reject" and sends my emails back to me. Recently, he emailed me asking if those "Automatic" responses (that he manually keys in) were annoying me. They aren't, but apparently that's been Donovan's agenda since March 2010.
12:12, you've summed it up well, thank you.
Email, Incoming, from Allentown City Council Vice President (for now) "W" Mike Donovan ...
On July 16, 2010 4:22:31 PM, "W" Mike Donovan wrote:
[Reject] Don't you love automatic response technology in email? Eh?
-------
((Me))
Your last one wasn't automatic, eh?
Vote them out for sure.
I second that one.
Join Our Justice Mission
I'm still kind-of wondering where "unmoderated" blogs' comments end up being liable to the owner of the original blog. And why the owner has to apologize for those comments.
Stop wondering, it's amazingly simple as 1, 2, 3 ...
1. Evil sadist cretins were posting cruel and libelous comments, directed against an Allentown family, at Donovan's blog, for a month.
2. Donovan popped in about half-way through this cyber assault (and he had been reading and commenting all along) w/ a comment of his own that endorsed and approved of all this vile ...
"I am just going to let all comments run, they are fun to read."
... in effect, "moderating" them all "in," and owning them. They're Donovan's now.
3. Is Donovan "legally liable" ... I'm hoping we don't have to find out, but we're certainly prepared to--
The easier end game here for everyone would be for Donovan to admit to his tragically awful lapse of good judgement ... and to apologize.
This ain't rocket science.
Is everyone getting the irony and hypocrisy of "Civility Zen Master Donovan" hiding behind the issue of "moderated/un-moderated" blog comments as his justification for allowing, and encouraging (he basically "green lighted" them) unspeakably cruel and sadistic comments, bully-directed against a family suffering through a devastating personal tragedy?
Now this isn't a legal term but Donovan (an elected official remember) is basically of the position that he should be able to switch from his "civil" pose, and into his "shit-head" reality, and that nobody (e.g., his TARGETS) should have a problem with this?
Well, I have a big problem w/ this and I don't really give a shit what the current cyber space law is.
We'll get it changed and we'll use Donovan as our (legal) battering ram.
It's Donovan's call ... ;D
Yep.
And if HE prevails .. well .. what will he have accomplished?
Keeping the blogosphere safe for evil sadist trolls to emotionally cyber-torture whomever they please?
Nice work, Mike.
Not quite in the same league as enacting a grandstanding cell phone ban while driving, now, is it?
BTW, these same civic-minded "New Boy Network" types stop in for "Pints and Policy" at The Brew Works and then weave home. No cell phone calls though, thank God.
"... in effect, "moderating" them all "in," and owning them. They're Donovan's now. "
Or. Washing his hands of the entire thing.
It's funny how much you seem to bitch about one person, when you, with your fantastic brain (one would assume) could be doing so much more to help society. Like, start a fundraiser, or help a charity, or cure AIDS or something.
But no, by all means, continue harping on one person from here to eternity. That makes a lot of sense.
You haven't been paying attention.
I'm taking on far more than "1 person."
There are dozens I'm taking on.
And when you get dragged through,
what we've been dragged through,
(and do keep me posted on this),
I'll consider taking your advice.
It's my life and I'll do what I want.
(almost forgot)
You shouldn't be blogging at work.
Domain Name > (Unknown)
IP Address > 167.155.144.# (PPL Corporation)
ISP > PPL Corporation
Time of Visit > Jul 23 2010 4:18:55 pm
Visit Length > 18 minutes 4 seconds
Related Info ;D
Visit Length Correction (Mea Culpa)
Domain Name > (Unknown)
IP Address > 167.155.144.# (PPL Corporation)
ISP > PPL Corporation
Time of Visit > Jul 23 2010 4:18:55 pm
Visit Length > 49 minutes 7 seconds
See how easy it is to apologize, Mike? ;D
From earlier today, I'd contact PPL IT Dep't first thing Monday morning, just sayin' ...
Domain Name > (Unknown)
IP Address > 167.155.144.# (PPL Corporation)
ISP > PPL Corporation
Time of Visit > Jul 23 2010 1:32:31 pm
Visit Length > 52 minutes 14 seconds
Villas, track down that PPL jerk-troll and give it a nice electrical shock.
Will do.
And like in the recent KCP work-stalker snare, we already have a real good idea who "PPL" is.
Around 5:03pm, "Pee" posted another comment, this one very vile, and very vicious, and b/c he was so unnerved and unhinged at being called out by our SiteMeter(R), he actually admitted to blogging from work. Merci. We're keeping this comment unpublished until the proper authorities can review it but it brayed, in part ...
"Wow, it's an IP address. Like magic or something. It doesn't intimidate me. A slow work day means at least I have a job."
For now.
Related Info
Bill, you should definitely get the Cedar Crest College President's "opinion" on Donovan's blogging ethics. It's time.
I tend to agree.
Sadly, the Allentown "Ethics" Board, The Morning Call "newspaper," City Councilors Julio Guridy, Ray O'Connell, Jeanette Eichenwald, D'Amore/Schlossberg/Schweyer, and Mike Hanlon haven't given us any opinions we liked, so we've been forced to look elsewhere at Cedar Crest.
Our hands are tied.
Can;'t say I blame you Bill, all the systems that should have served you are broken.
Which systems around here aren't broken?
... as the cogs in the systems benefit from the breakage.
... and the locals are so used to mediocrity and shit service that nobody ever calls a repairman.
Allentown. Love it or leave it I guess, cuz it ain't never changing.
Post a Comment